Fault Atlas › form-035

Undated contradiction

Contradiction sans date

Wrong valueIrreducible: needs meaninglayer: ⑧ coherenceinjection: ALTERmigrated unreviewed

Damage in the graph

Wrong value — a property, number or date is wrong.

Can code cancel it?

No.

Can a deletion-only repair restore the truth?

no — deletion cannot restore this; judgment of 2026-09-09, to be measured.

Which truth can judge it

truth by construction, an official registry, the dated future, a closed world.

Where it was seen

observation 2026-08 (272 Europe PMC JATS articles) · 2026-08-08 · house observer (LLM agent), see report

MEASURED on 2026-08-08 on the 272 articles of the internal corpus: 15,049 of the 16,411 body paragraphs (92 %) contain NO year. The undated statement is therefore the norm, not the exception — and two undated statements cannot be separated by date. (Probe: count of <p> in <body> carrying a 19xx/20xx year token.)

Original note (fr)

MESURÉ le 08/08/2026 sur les 272 articles de (internal corpus of 272 JATS articles) : 15 049 des 16 411 paragraphes de corps (92 %) ne contiennent AUCUNE année. L'affirmation non datée est donc la norme, pas l'exception — et deux affirmations non datées ne peuvent pas être départagées par la date. (Sonde : comptage des <p> du <body> portant un jeton d'année 19xx/20xx.)

Specimens

Specimens not yet transcribed into this record.

History

2026-08-09 catalogue line 35 — GOLDEN (kept for the benchmark): irreducible or silent false — Korela For Science
2026-09-09 migrated; classified damage=WRONG_VALUE injection=ALTER (judgment, unreviewed by a second reader) — Fault Atlas migration
2026-09-09 internal tool paths removed from observation notes before publication; wording otherwise unchanged — Fault Atlas

Record: atlas.json · source file on GitHub · row in the data explorer