Fault Atlas by Loxyn

Fault Atlas › form-116

Open peer-review furniture

Mobilier de relecture ouverte

Spurious edgeSilent false: code cannot see it from insidelayer: ④ extractioninjection: INSERTmigrated unreviewed

Damage in the graph

Spurious edge — a relation the source never asserted.

Can code cancel it?

No.

Can a deletion-only repair restore the truth?

yes — the faulty edge can be deleted.

Which truth can judge it

truth by construction, a curated database, a closed world.

Where it was seen

observation 2026-08 (272 Europe PMC JATS articles) · 2026-08-08 · house observer (LLM agent), see report

MEASURED on 2026-08-08 on the internal corpus (272 JATS XML): 5/272 articles (2 %) carry named open peer-review furniture (peer review file, reviewer report, editor's evaluation, eLife assessment) and 6/272 (2 %) a <sub-article article-type="...review...">; the neighbouring furniture of author declarations is at 203/272 (75 %). Observed on 2026-08-08 on 15 articles 2023-2026 (VERDICT old versus modern, N10) — absent from the 1957-1987 corpus.

Original note (fr)

MESURÉ le 08/08/2026 sur (internal corpus of 272 JATS articles) (272 XML JATS) : 5/272 articles (2 %) portent un mobilier de relecture ouverte nommé (peer review file, reviewer report, editor's evaluation, eLife assessment) et 6/272 (2 %) un <sub-article article-type="...review..." > ; le mobilier voisin de déclarations sur les auteurs est lui à 203/272 (75 %). Observée le 08/08 sur 15 articles 2023-2026 (VERDICT ancien contre moderne, N10) — absente du corpus 1957-1987.

Specimens

Specimens not yet transcribed into this record.

History

Record: atlas.json · source file on GitHub · row in the data explorer