Retraction status not linked to the retracted record

Found by Loxyn SAS, Lyon — September 2026 — PubMed substrate and other corpora (Voûte) · first seen 2026-08-18

Anachronismfrom: Loxyn SAS, LyonUnclassifiedlayer: ⑧ coherenceinjection: DELETEproposed

Damage in the graph

Anachronism — a fact outside its validity interval, or a superseded status kept.

Can code cancel it?

No. not assessed by the observer; to be classified by the second reader.

Can a deletion-only repair restore the truth?

partial — deleting the anachronistic edge removes a fact that was true within its validity interval; the true repair bounds the validity, it does not delete (reading of Coralie Bagnol-Lebon, 2026-09-09).

Which truth can judge it

an official registry.

Where it was seen

PubMed/MEDLINE baseline frozen 2026-08-18 (39,994,988 records), liens/notice_correction, descriptors D016440 (Retracted Publication) and D016441 (Retraction of Publication) · 2026-08-18 · Claude Voûte (LLM agent), session 8d9c5098, from the Substrat measurement files · Loxyn SAS, Lyon

File DISCORDANCE-retractations-1429-notices.json (Substrat, 2026-08-18): 1,429 records; "D016440_without_link 696 · D016441_without_link 685 · erratum_self_loop 48"; reftypes "RetractionIn 1,038 · none 302 · ErratumFor 49".

Original note (fr)

Fichier DISCORDANCE-retractations-1429-notices.json (Substrat, 18-08-2026) : 1 429 notices ; « D016440_sans_lien 696 · D016441_sans_lien 685 · erratum_autoboucle 48 » ; reftypes « RetractionIn 1 038 · aucun 302 · ErratumFor 49 ».

Specimens

Specimens not yet transcribed into this record.

History

2026-09-09 proposed by the Voûte Claude in 'FORMES-PUBMED-pour-Fault-Atlas (09-09-2026)' (part 1; final file sha256 51a338add43cd071…), form 14 of 23; effect on a graph: A retracted article stays a living node with no edge to its retraction; 48 errata correct themselves (loop). Prevalence: measured: 1,429 discordant records over 3,122,924 correction links. — Claude Voûte (LLM agent), session 8d9c5098, from the Substrat measurement files
2026-09-09 converted to a record; class, prevention and the novel/variant question left to the second reader — Fault Atlas
2026-09-09 repair.reachable_by_deletion changed from yes to partial: a deletion loses the fact's past validity; only a spurious edge is fully repaired by deletion — Coralie Bagnol-Lebon (second reader), applied by Fault Atlas

Record: atlas.json · source file on GitHub · row in the data explorer