Fault Atlas › form-169

Domain assigned from the record's primary topic, not from the keyword

Found by Loxyn SAS, Lyon — September 2026 — PubMed substrate and other corpora (Voûte) · first seen 2026-09-06

Wrong labelfrom: Loxyn SAS, LyonUnclassifiedlayer: ⑦ schemainjection: ALTERproposed

Damage in the graph

Wrong label — an entity or relation type is wrong.

Can code cancel it?

No. not assessed by the observer; to be classified by the second reader.

Can a deletion-only repair restore the truth? classified, not measured

partial — an extra label can be deleted, a missing one cannot be added.

Which truth can judge it

a curated database.

Where it was seen

OpenAlex snapshot 2026 (works parquet), read 2026-09-06, primary_topic.domain · 2026-09-06 · Claude Voûte (LLM agent), session 8d9c5098, from the night reports of 2026-09-06/09 · Loxyn SAS, Lyon

2026-09-06: "Physical Sciences 51.8 M records, Life Sciences 16.5 M — a factor of three"; "for a cross-cutting keyword ('Medicine', 'Computer science') this choice is arbitrary"; "1.55 M records have no domain at all".

Original note (fr)

06-09-2026 : « Physical Sciences 51,8 M de notices, Life Sciences 16,5 M — un facteur trois » ; « pour un mot-clé transversal ("Medicine", "Computer science") ce choix est arbitraire » ; « 1,55 M de notices n'ont pas de domaine du tout ».

Specimens

Specimens not yet transcribed into this record.

History

2026-09-09 proposed by the Voûte Claude in 'FORMES-PUBMED-pour-Fault-Atlas (09-09-2026)' part 2 (sha256 51a338add43cd071…), form 28 of 40; effect on a graph: The domain of a subject is that of the majority of its records, not a property of the subject; a cross-cutting keyword is filed at random. Prevalence: 1.55 M records without domain; the rest seen, not counted. — Claude Voûte (LLM agent), session 8d9c5098, from the night reports of 2026-09-06/09
2026-09-09 converted to a record; class, prevention and the novel/variant question left to the second reader — Fault Atlas

Record: atlas.json · source file on GitHub · this record as JSON · row in the data explorer