forms: form-016
This data as json
| id | name | damage | class | injection | layer | status | organisation | campaign | cancellable_by_code | reachable_by_deletion | judgeable_by | observations | observed_absent_in | name_fr | legacy_line | version | record |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| form-016 | Fact redundancy across documents | CORPUS_PARAMETER | REFUSABLE | DUPLICATE | ⑩ retrieval | migrated_unreviewed | Loxyn SAS, Lyon | August 2026 — observation campaign (Korela For Science) | 1 | no | 1 | Redondance du fait | 16 | 1 | {"id": "form-016", "version": 1, "legacy_line": 16, "name": "Fact redundancy across documents", "name_fr": "Redondance du fait", "origin": {"organisation": "Loxyn SAS, Lyon", "campaign": "August 2026 — observation campaign (Korela For Science)", "contact": "contact@loxyn.ai"}, "damage": "CORPUS_PARAMETER", "class": "REFUSABLE", "layer": "⑩ retrieval", "injection": "DUPLICATE", "legacy_severity": "G4", "legacy_mechanism": "M9", "status": "migrated_unreviewed", "seen": [{"corpus": "observation 2026-08 (Europe PMC JATS 2023-2026 and PubMed abstracts)", "date": "2026-08-08", "observer": "house observer (LLM agent), see report", "excerpt": "MESURÉ le 08/08/2026 sur 272 articles Europe PMC accès libre 2023-2026 (internal corpus of 272 JATS articles) : 1 753 énoncés chiffrés distincts extraits des résumés, dont 1 749 à UN SEUL témoin (99,8 %). Les 4 seuls énoncés à deux témoins ne sont pas des faits : licence Creative Commons et avis de rétractation. En revanche 60 articles sur 272 (22 %) répètent le MÊME énoncé dans le résumé et dans le corps — deux ancrages pour un seul témoin. Contrôle positif de la sonde : le même article sous deux noms → 2/2 énoncés vus à deux témoins.", "lang": "fr", "excerpt_en": "MEASURED on 2026-08-08 on 272 open-access Europe PMC articles 2023-2026 (internal corpus): 1,753 distinct numerical statements extracted from the abstracts, of which 1,749 have a SINGLE witness (99.8 %). The only 4 statements with two witnesses are not facts: a Creative Commons licence and a retraction notice. However 60 articles out of 272 (22 %) repeat the SAME statement in the abstract and in the body — two anchors for a single witness. Positive control of the probe: the same article under two names → 2/2 statements seen with two witnesses.", "organisation": "Loxyn SAS, Lyon", "corpus_id": "corpus-europe-pmc-jats-2023-2026"}], "specimens": {"cases": [], "counter_examples": []}, "prevention": {"cancellable_by_code": true, "refusal_clause": "handle, or abstain and declare — never guess"}, "repair": {"reachable_by_deletion": "no", "note": "deletion cannot restore this; classified by judgment on 2026-09-09, not measured — the EUR-Lex loop will measure it"}, "judgeable_by": [], "history": [{"date": "2026-08-09", "event": "catalogue line 16 — DEFEATED (cancelled by code): filter written and green on the bench", "by": "Korela For Science"}, {"date": "2026-09-09", "event": "migrated; classified damage=CORPUS_PARAMETER injection=DUPLICATE (judgment, unreviewed by a second reader)", "by": "Fault Atlas migration"}, {"date": "2026-08-08", "event": "house filter exists with 3 cases and 1 counter-examples (bench green=True); specimens to be transcribed into this record", "by": "Korela For Science"}, {"date": "2026-09-09", "event": "internal tool paths removed from observation notes before publication; wording otherwise unchanged", "by": "Fault Atlas"}]} |