forms: form-185
This data as json
| id | name | damage | class | injection | layer | status | organisation | campaign | cancellable_by_code | reachable_by_deletion | judgeable_by | observations | observed_absent_in | name_fr | legacy_line | version | record |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| form-185 | Text format served depends on the act's age (404 in one format, 200 in another) | MISSING | REFUSABLE | FORMAT | ② reading | proposed | Loxyn SAS, Lyon | September 2026 — EUR-Lex collection for the Answer Key (Alexandrie) | 1 | no | registry | 1 | 1 | {"id": "form-185", "version": 1, "name": "Text format served depends on the act's age (404 in one format, 200 in another)", "origin": {"organisation": "Loxyn SAS, Lyon", "campaign": "September 2026 — EUR-Lex collection for the Answer Key (Alexandrie)", "contact": "contact@loxyn.ai"}, "damage": "MISSING", "class": "REFUSABLE", "layer": "② reading", "injection": "FORMAT", "status": "proposed", "seen": [{"corpus": "Cellar REST API, lot B (texts of repealed acts absent from the dump), 2026-09-09", "document": "acts of 2026 answer 404 in text/html and 200 in application/xhtml+xml; acts of 1985 the reverse; 141 entries wrongly classified before the fix, set aside in index.jsonl.errone-141-formats-incomplets", "date": "2026-09-09", "observer": "Alexandrie (LLM agent, collection session), from the EUR-Lex collection manifest", "organisation": "Loxyn SAS, Lyon", "excerpt": "Mesuré au lot B, 09-09-2026 : les formats servis par Cellar sont exclusifs selon l'âge de l'acte — l'acte de 2026 rend 404 en text/html et 200 en application/xhtml+xml, l'acte de 1985 l'inverse. Une liste de formats qui omettait xhtml+xml a classé 141 actes récents « sans texte » avant correction ; ces 141 entrées sont mises de côté, pas supprimées, et un test de non-régression passe sur les quatre cas (119 Ko et 127 Ko pour 2026, 5 Ko et 6 Ko pour 1985). Un repli « */* » classait aussi la notice RDF comme « image seule » : statut distinct ajouté, « aucun format textuel servi ». Sans ce garde-fou, le résultat publié aurait été « Cellar ne sert aucun texte pour les actes récents » — un faux.", "excerpt_en": "Measured in lot B, 2026-09-09: the formats served by Cellar are exclusive by the act's age — a 2026 act answers 404 in text/html and 200 in application/xhtml+xml, a 1985 act the reverse. A format list that omitted xhtml+xml classified 141 recent acts as 'no text' before the fix; those 141 entries are set aside, not deleted, and a non-regression test passes on the four cases (119 KB and 127 KB for 2026, 5 KB and 6 KB for 1985). A '*/*' fallback also classified the RDF notice as 'image only': a distinct status was added, 'no textual format served'. Without this guard, the published result would have been 'Cellar serves no text for recent acts' — a false one.", "lang": "fr", "probe": "probes/2026-09/form-185-format-by-era.sh"}], "specimens": {"cases": [], "counter_examples": []}, "prevention": {"cancellable_by_code": true, "refusal_clause": "try each textual format in turn and record the MIME type actually served; a non-textual answer is recorded as such, never as an absence of the act"}, "repair": {"reachable_by_deletion": "no", "note": "deletion cannot restore this; classified by judgment, not measured — the EUR-Lex loop will measure it"}, "judgeable_by": ["registry"], "related": ["form-121"], "history": [{"date": "2026-09-09", "event": "proposed from the EUR-Lex collection reports of 2026-09-09; effect on a graph: A collector that asks for one format misses whole generations of acts and reports a false absence of text; the graph built from it lacks every act of one era. Prevalence: measured on 141 entries and 4 test cases; share by era to be measured at the end of lot B.", "by": "Alexandrie (LLM agent, collection session), from the EUR-Lex collection manifest"}, {"date": "2026-09-09", "event": "converted to a record; class set from the collector's own refusal clause where one exists; to be reviewed by a second reader", "by": "Fault Atlas"}, {"date": "2026-09-09", "event": "exact probe attached and re-run: probes/2026-09/form-185-format-by-era.sh", "by": "Fault Atlas maintainer"}], "probes": [{"file": "probes/2026-09/form-185-format-by-era.sh", "kind": "http", "corpus_id": "corpus-2026-09-eurlex", "written": "2026-09-09", "run": "sh probes/2026-09/form-185-format-by-era.sh", "result": {"date": "2026-09-09", "count": 2, "of": 3, "by": "Fault Atlas maintainer (Loxyn), live on the public endpoint", "examples": [["32026D1970", ["2026 act: application/xhtml+xml 200 · text/html 404 · Formex 404"]], ["31985L0374", ["1985 act: application/xhtml+xml 404 · text/html 200 · Formex 404"]], ["31968R5759", ["1968 act: 404 in all three text formats"]]], "carriers_file": "probes/results/form-185-format-by-era.json"}, "matches_excerpt": true, "note": "Re-run live on three acts: 2026 act served in xhtml+xml only, 1985 act in text/html only, 1968 act in no text format at all."}]} |